• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • The Fine Print
    • Disclaimer
    • Copyright
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Paul Ooi Modelworks
  • Nav Social Menu

    • Email
    • Instagram
Paul Ooi Modelworks

Paul Ooi Modelworks

Building a better world, one scale model at a time

  • Index
    • Aircraft
      • WW1 Aircraft
      • Inter-War Aircraft
      • WW2 Allied Aircraft
      • WW2 Axis Aircraft
      • Modern Aircraft
    • Armored Fighting Vehicles
    • Ships
      • WW1 Ships
      • Inter-War Ships
      • WW2 Allied Ships
      • WW2 Axis Ships
      • Modern Ships
    • NordicCon Show
    • Figures
    • Buildings
    • Sci-Fi
    • Miscellaneous
  • Tutorials
    • Tutorial 1: Making a Wooden Platform Helipad
    • Tutorial 2: Wooden Hard Stand for Aircraft
    • Tutorial 3: Filling Large Plastic Seams
    • Tutorial 4: Diorama, Sicily 1943
    • Tutorial 5: Making a Gun Emplacement with Earthworks
    • Tutorial 6: Basic figure painting (1/35 scale or 54mm)
    • Tutorial 7: Filling Large Mouse Bite Gouges
    • Tutorial 8: Frames for Vacuum Formed Clear Canopies
Home / Ships / WW1 Ships / Battle of Penang Part 2: SMS Emden

Battle of Penang Part 2: SMS Emden

WW1 Ships

Among naval historians, the SMS Emden (built 1908) and her crew belong to a special group of unique ships that became legendary for their daring exploits in the face of overwhelming odds. After giving the Allied navies around the Indian Ocean a big chase, capturing and sinking ships along the way, Emden finally met her end at the Battle of Cocos at the hands of HMAS Sydney. 2 weeks before that, she made an audacious raid on Penang, then a British port controlling the northern passage into the Malacca Straits from the Andaman Sea. When I was growing up in Penang, we made frequent crossings in the harbor ferry and used to imagine all kinds of sea battles being fought there. Little did we know that we were a lot closer to reality than we realized.

Attributed to Deutsches Bundesarchiv, DVM 10 Bild-23-61-13 / CC-BY-SA

The Battle of Penang began in the early hours of 28th October 1914 when the Emden steamed full speed through the North Channel of Penang Roads spotting a fake fourth funnel and flying the British Royal Navy ensign. Harbor lookouts and French patrol craft took her for the HMS Yarmouth, a Town class light cruiser with 4 smoke stacks. Steaming into Georgetown Harbor, the Emden noted that the city was fully lit and could make out the silhouette of the Zhemchug anchored off Fort Pier. She launched her starboard torpedo at very close range which struck the Zhemchug close to the aft funnel. Once the torpedo struck, she at once fired her guns at the Zhemchug’s forecastle, injuring and killing many sleeping sailors.

Sketch from the New York Times, 20th October 1914

Moving past the stricken cruiser, the Emden spotted the shape of the French torpedo gunship d’Iberville and possibly several more allied torpedo boats to the south and may have decided at that point to turn around and leave the harbor. On her way out, the Emden fired her port torpedo at the Zhemchug striking the magazine and broke the latter into two. As she steamed out of the harbor towards open sea, the French destroyer Mousquet attempted to intercept but was also sunk with gunfire. The British colonial authorities and Allied navies were totally devastated by the raid as news of the Emden’s attack spread through the local population. My maternal grandfather was at the Penang Esplanade as they brought severely wounded Russian survivors to shore. One of my grand aunts who was born that week in 1914 was nicknamed “Emden”.

The 1/700 scale resin kit of the Emden is made by Midship. The kit included several metal parts for the searchlights and lifeboats and also a phtoetched fret for railings, platforms and a leftover vestige from the 19th century, shrouds. For the masts, the kit provided the builder with a single 6 inch section of R20 brass wire and you need to build the rest. These resin kits make nice, rare ship models but they are not for the beginner.


I start out by spraying the cleaned resin hull and funnels with Tamiya XF25 Light Sea Grey. Then the linoleum decks are painted with a 75% Tamiya XF69 NATO Brown + 25% XF2 White while the wooden decks are painted with a mix of 75% XF60 Dark Yellow + 25% XF2.

The funnels were molded without the characteristic rails around them that were visible on the Emden. Realizing that unless I can get very uniformed fine wiring wrapped around the funnels without looking out of scale, I used a different technique instead. After painting the basic XF25, I used a flexible piece of Dymo plastic tape as a ruler and a pencil to trace the lines. After that, I sprayed a light dusting of XF25 lightened a few shades with white over the pencil lines and it looked just right.

The gun turrets and railings were assembled next and these fitted into place easily. I really liked the long platform walkway lined with lifelines on the port side of the midship section, visible in this picture running between the forecastle to the quarterdeck along the three funnels.

HMS Yarmouth, photograph from Imperial War Museum

Now comes the tricky part, literally. As I mentioned earlier, Captain von Müller had used a fake funnel to gain entry into the harbor. No photographs exist of this structure but references to a similar ruse on the Graf Spee 25 years later are helpful. The structure on the Emden were described to be a creation of wooden sections, canvas and paint. I started out making a flat panel wooden frame using bronze wires. Once properly set, I stretched aluminum foil as fabric over that frame. When mounting the deceptive structure over the gun director platform, I also had to wrap some foil over that beautiful feature, then paint the whole thing XF25 to match the hull. The false funnel was convincing in poor light from a distance. The structure was also secured with several cables to the deck and main mast.


After that, I started constructing both the fore mast and the main mast. I used brass wires of three different sizes to build these structures. The kit came with several platforms for search lights that had to be slipped like rings onto the masts before attaching to the deck. After the masts were installed, I attached the shroud lines that came in the photoetch fret and then installed rigging.

Next, the life boats and davits were installed. The lifeboats themselves are painted Light Silk Grey (almost white), which can be mixed with Light Ghost Grey FS36375 (or IJN grey XF12) 50% + White 50%.

For the second part of the ruse, I made two battle flags, one British and the other Imperial German. The most likely method to achieve a quick flag changeover was to hitch the Royal Navy ensign first to the flag pulley line with the German ensign hitched further down on the same line, so that when the first flag was lowered, the same motion would pull the German ensign up. The Emden’s captain must have spent their layover time in Diego Garcia dreaming up these tricks.

Finally, the lifelines were added to the bow and stern sections. The Emden is ready to join the Zhemchug on the diorama.

Just to add some interest to the diorama, I made 2 Asian watercraft that plied Georgetown harbor in those days. I carved these out of pine wood chips. First was a little sampan (shallow draft boat) with a large awning to ferry passengers to and from shore. The other was a coastal trader that was common in Penang and Singapore in those days, a Fujianese junk called a Tuakow. These came as either single masted vessels or larger 3-masted ones. The junks were always colorfully decorated at the bow and stern.

Enjoy the pictures.

Contrary to Allied reports, the Zhemchug was almost equal in size to the Emden and had heavier 120mm guns to the Emden's 105mm.
Up goes the German ensign! The British ensign can be seen near the deck.
Emden guns start firing on the Zhemchug
The Emden ran parallel to the Zhemchug at 23 knots, evident from the wake.
The Chinese junk anchored close to the Zhemchug. The Russian survivors were rescued by harbor craft like this one
>
How the Zhemchug would have appeared to the Emden's searchlights at 5:15am that morning

January 27, 2013 · 9 Comments

Previous Post: « Battle of Penang Part 1: The Zhemchug Жемчуг
Next Post: USS Nassau CVE-16, The Little Princess »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments

  1. Igor says

    December 16, 2013 at 8:35 pm

    Dear Paul,

    Could you please tell how you made the smoke cloud from torpedo explosion & gunshots from Emden?

    Regards,
    Igor

    Reply
    • Paul says

      December 18, 2013 at 3:30 am

      Dear Igor,

      These smoke flashes and explosion effects have to be carefully planned even as I build the models. I use brass wire cores for the basic shape of the explosion, coat it with light weight white plaster, and then paint them. Once dry, they are attached just like any other part of the model.

      Paul

      Reply
  2. Andrew Hwang says

    December 25, 2013 at 7:10 pm

    I am hoping to persuade a modeller/collector who is willing to display his diorama or dioramas in a museum (on loan or even outright purchase if within budget) in conjunction with a 100th anniversary commemorative exhibition of the Emden Raid in Penang Harbour planned for 2014 in Georgetown and Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Besides the Emden and Zhemchug, we hope to also feature the Mosquet and the Sydney and perhaps more of the flotilla anchored in the harbour on the night of the Raid. Please contact me on my email address. Thank you.

    Reply
  3. éjac sur la tronche says

    May 24, 2014 at 2:00 am

    Tiens je comptais justement faire un petit poste semblable à celui ci

    Reply
  4. X says

    June 20, 2014 at 7:02 pm

    On va vous dire que ce n’est nullement erroné !!!

    Reply
  5. Sosezi says

    August 28, 2014 at 5:20 am

    Outstanding job!!

    Reply
    • Paul says

      August 31, 2014 at 10:05 pm

      Thank you!

      Reply
  6. Liam DuBois says

    June 17, 2015 at 6:04 am

    Von Mucke gave an excellent first hand account of HMS Emden’s short lived adventures, including the construction of the 4th smoke pipe. He testified that no other deceptive measures were ever employed, and no British ensigns were ever displayed.

    Reply
    • Paul says

      June 23, 2015 at 1:33 pm

      There are conflicting accounts about the ensign. Allied sources consistently mentioned the “home-made” ensign while German sources denied it. You can choose either side’s version of the event in any portrayal. I made my presentation of this diorama in front of Russian and German embassy officials in great detail in October 2014 on the 100th anniversary of the sinking. So far, no one has yet to launch a diplomatic protest 🙂

      Reply

Primary Sidebar

Hey! It is nice to meet you!

Paul Ooi Modelworks welcomes casual visitors browsing, and enjoying the pictures as well as more serious fellow modelers looking for tips and references on the art of making miniatures and relishing in the challenge. I will be more than happy to answer any questions you may have about the models.

Please feel free to leave a comment or a question.

  • Email
  • Instagram

NEVER MISS A POST

Member of International List of Scale Model Related Web Sites


International List of Scale Model Related Web Sites

  • NordicCon 2012 – Part 1 30.3k views | posted on 10/01/2012
  • USS Iwo Jima LPH-2, the Navy’s Mailed Fist 14.7k views | posted on 05/13/2012
  • British 25 Pounder Field Gun and Quad Tractor 13.6k views | posted on 05/05/2013
  • Oshkosh M-ATV MRAP: Surviving an IED Part 1 12.5k views | posted on 11/15/2013
Paul Ooi Modelworks

NEVER MISS A POST

Sign up for notification on new posts.

Footer

  • Email
  • Instagram

Categories

  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Copyright

© 2011–2023 · Paul Ooi Modelworks · All Rights Reserved